About & Methodology

What we document, how we assess evidence, and the principles guiding the archive.

Our mission

Bihar Hate Archive (BHA) documents hate speech, regional prejudice, and discrimination targeting Bihari people. We aim to build a careful, evidence-based public record that supports awareness, research, and accountability.

Our focus is on attacks against people because of who they are. Criticism of Bihar’s government, institutions, policies, or an individual’s conduct does not qualify simply because it concerns Bihar.

Our definitions

Anti-Bihari hate speech

Expression that attacks, dehumanises, demeans, threatens, or advocates exclusion or harm against people because of their actual or perceived Bihari origin or identity. This includes associated language or accent when used to target that identity. Classification depends on meaning and context, rather than particular words alone.

Anti-Bihari discrimination

Unjustified unequal treatment or exclusion connected to actual or perceived Bihari identity, including in employment, housing, education, or services. Assessment identifies the treatment involved and the evidence connecting it to that identity. Not every difference in treatment constitutes discrimination.

These are BHA’s editorial definitions, informed by the UN working definition of hate speech and human-rights guidance on non-discrimination. Their application to Bihari regional identity is BHA’s adaptation. There is no universally agreed legal definition of hate speech.

Inclusion in this archive is an editorial assessment, not a finding of criminal liability. Indian legal provisions, including BNS Section 196, have their own requirements; legal conclusions require separate assessment.

What we include and exclude

We look for an identifiable connection between Bihari identity and the expression or treatment involved, supported by verifiable evidence. These examples are hypothetical; each real report requires review.

Include when verified

“Biharis are inherently criminals.”

A derogatory generalisation targeting people because of their identity.

Include when verified

“Do not rent to Biharis.”

Advocacy of discriminatory exclusion. It does not by itself prove that a rental was refused.

Include when verified

A documented refusal to hire someone because they are Bihari.

Discriminatory treatment where evidence connects the refusal to Bihari identity.

Include when verified

Calling for attacks on Bihari workers.

Advocacy of violence; assess threats and possible incitement in context.

Exclude on its own

“Bihar’s government has failed to improve schools.”

Criticism of government or policy does not itself attack people based on identity.

Exclude on its own

Reporting an individual’s misconduct, or neutrally describing someone as Bihari.

Regional origin does not make criticism of an individual’s conduct identity-based abuse.

Review attribution

Quoting hateful language to report or condemn it.

Assess the original expression separately. Quotation does not establish endorsement by the person reporting it.

Review context

Using “Bihari” as an insult, or in a joke, meme, or satire.

Examine meaning, target, and surrounding material. Neither the word alone nor someone taking offence establishes hate speech.

Humour, satire, reclaimed language, and translations need particular care. Calling something a joke does not automatically exempt identity-based abuse. Disagreement, offensiveness, or a mention of Bihar alone is also insufficient. Material whose authenticity or necessary context cannot be established should not be published as an established incident.

How we verify

01

Find the original source

Review the original post, recording, document, or other available source. Check attribution, dates, and whether screenshots or clips have been altered or taken out of context.

02

Read the surrounding context

Examine the thread, full recording, or surrounding statements. Check who is speaking, who is targeted, and whether the material quotes, reports, condemns, or endorses the expression. Check translations against the original where possible.

03

Separate evidence from allegations

An authentic screenshot of an accusation proves that the accusation was made; it does not prove the underlying allegation. Seek corroboration where available and distinguish observed facts from claims and unresolved information.

04

Review before publication

Assess the identity connection and appropriate categories, check for duplicate reports, and consider alternative interpretations. Researchers may prepare assessments; the BHA Admin makes the publication decision. Borderline cases should receive another review where possible.

05

Preserve a clear record

Approved records receive public Case IDs and relevant source details and supporting evidence. Pending submissions do not receive public Case IDs. Handle personal information with care and avoid publishing unnecessary private details.

How we classify

Categories describe the conduct supported by the evidence. They can overlap, and stronger labels require stronger support.

Derogatory stereotyping

Negative generalisations portraying Bihari people as inherently inferior, dishonest, or otherwise unworthy.

Identity-based abuse

Slurs or targeted degrading expression tied to actual or perceived Bihari identity.

Dehumanisation

Expression presenting people as less than human or undeserving of basic dignity because of that identity.

Discriminatory exclusion or treatment

Calls to deny opportunities or services, or documented unequal treatment linked to Bihari identity. Advocacy of exclusion and an actual denial are assessed separately.

Threats or advocacy of violence

Threatening harm or encouraging attacks against people because they are Bihari. Assessment considers the statement and its context.

Broader patterns

Systemic discrimination requires evidence of an institutional practice or wider pattern. An individual incident alone does not establish such a pattern.

For possible incitement, the Rabat Plan of Action provides a higher-threshold framework considering context, the speaker, intent, content and form, reach, and the likelihood of harm, including imminence. It is not a test that makes every insult a criminal offence.

Calls for violence are not automatically classified as genocidal rhetoric. That description requires a separate, careful assessment of evidence concerning advocacy of group destruction. Editorial classifications do not establish that a legal offence has occurred.

Corrections and contact

If you believe a record contains an error, lacks important context, or has been misclassified, email BHA with the Case ID or page URL, the issue, and supporting sources. You may also request reconsideration of a published record. The BHA Admin reviews correction requests and updates or removes records where warranted.

Avoid sending unnecessary sensitive personal information. For corrections or questions about these criteria, contact biharhatearchive@outlook.com.